I picked up Mafia: The Old Country on launch day and planned to blast through the story in a weekend, but I quickly got obsessed with unlocking every trophy. I messed up my first playthrough by rushing past side content and missing three missable trophies, so I had to start over from scratch. After 28 hours of gameplay, I finally got the platinum, so I put together this complete mafia the old country trophy list plus all the tips I wish I’d had before I started. You won’t have to replay entire chapters or waste hours hunting for hidden content if you follow this guide.
Full Mafia: The Old Country Trophy List Breakdown (Platinum, Gold, Silver, Bronze)
This mafia the old country trophy list is sorted by rarity, so you can track which ones you’re missing as you play through the story and open world. There are 42 total trophies to unlock: 1 platinum, 4 gold, 12 silver, and 25 bronze. 37 of the 42 total trophies are tied to story progression or optional open-world activities, so you won’t have to do any weird, overly complicated challenges to get most of them. No online trophies are required for platinum, which is a huge relief for players who don’t want to deal with random multiplayer lobbies or online server shutdowns down the line.
Only 5 trophies are truly missable, meaning you can’t go back and unlock them after you pass a certain story point. I missed two of these on my first playthrough, so I’ve marked them clearly below so you don’t make the same mistake:
- Family Loyalty: Complete all 6 side missions for Don Enzo before finishing Chapter 7, since he leaves the map permanently after that chapter ends.
- Ghost of Sicily: Take down 3 enemy outposts without triggering a single alarm, and don’t use any explosives even if no guards see you.
- Wine Collector: Find all 12 hidden vintage wine bottles scattered across the western countryside before Chapter 10, when the area gets blocked off by police roadblocks.
- Old School Driver: Win 3 street races using only the 1950s sedan you get in Chapter 2, no upgraded or purchased cars allowed for this trophy.
- Silent Enforcer: Eliminate 10 target hits using only your bare hands or a melee weapon, no guns or explosives count towards this total.
If you cross these 5 off your list first, you’ll be well on your way to completing the full mafia the old country trophy list without any hiccups. All other trophies can be unlocked after you finish the main story, so you don’t have to stress about them during your first run if you’re focused on the plot first.
Pro Tips to Unlock Trophies Faster Without Replaying Chapters
As you work through the mafia the old country trophy list, prioritize the missable ones first so you don’t have to restart your playthrough like I did. The biggest tip I can give you is to do side content as you unlock it, not wait until you finish the main story. A lot of side missions and collectible spots are only available during specific chapters, and they disappear once you move on to the next act.
Turn on the "missable objective" alert in your game settings before you start playing. Most players don’t even know this toggle exists, but it pops up a small notification on the top of your screen when you’re about to leave an area that has a missable collectible or side mission. It saved me from missing the Wine Collector trophy on my second playthrough, and it’s so easy to turn on. This small setting alone will save you hours of frustration when working through the mafia the old country trophy list.
You can also track specific trophies from the in-game menu, so pin the missable ones to your HUD to make sure you don’t forget about them. For example, if you pin the Silent Enforcer trophy, it will show you how many melee kills you’ve got so far every time you take down a target. That way you don’t have to guess how many more you need to unlock it.
Hidden Trophy Secrets Most Players Miss
8 of the trophies on the list are hidden by default, so they won’t show up on your in-game trophy screen until you unlock them. All hidden trophies are included in the mafia the old country trophy list above, so you don’t have to guess what you’re missing or look up random lists halfway through your playthrough. Most of the hidden trophies are story-related, but there are two that require specific actions you might not stumble on by accident.
The first is the gold hidden trophy “Last Man Standing”, which requires you to survive the final mission shootout without taking any damage. I thought I’d have to replay the entire game to get this, but you can restart the final mission checkpoint as many times as you want to get this trophy, no need to replay the whole game. Just restart the checkpoint right before the shootout starts if you take a single hit, and you’ll get it in 10 or 15 tries max.
The other hidden secret trophy is “Local Hero”, which you unlock by helping 20 random civilians around the open world. These random events pop up as small blue dots on your map, and they’re things like chasing a purse snatcher, helping an old lady carry groceries, or fixing a flat tire for a stranded driver. Most players ignore these events because they don’t give big cash or weapon rewards, but they’re fast to complete and you’ll probably hit 20 naturally if you stop for them as you drive around.
Common Trophy Unlock Glitches & How to Fix Them
I ran into two different glitches when I was working through the mafia the old country trophy list, and I saw dozens of other players reporting the same issues on community forums. The good news is both have easy fixes, so you don’t have to panic if a trophy doesn’t pop when you think it should.
The most common glitch is the Wine Collector trophy not popping even if you’ve found all 12 bottles. The fix for this is super simple: just go back to the first wine bottle you collected, interact with it again, and the trophy will pop immediately. The game sometimes doesn’t register the first bottle you pick up, so this trick works every time. I tested it myself when I ran into the glitch, and it worked on the first try.
The second common glitch is the Ghost of Sicily trophy not counting your outpost clears even if you didn’t trigger an alarm. The issue here is that explosives count as a “disturbance” even if no guards see or hear them, so you can’t use grenades or dynamite to take out outposts for this trophy. If you already tried that, just replay three outposts using only stealth takedowns, and the trophy will pop. Always back up your save file before starting a new chapter, just in case a glitch locks you out of a trophy. It only takes 30 seconds, and it can save you hours of replaying content.
Don’t let a few missed trophies or silly glitches ruin your run through one of the most immersive Mafia games ever made. This mafia the old country trophy list and guide has all the info you need to get that platinum on your first playthrough, no extra grinding or unnecessary replays required. If you run into a weird trophy issue or can’t find a specific collectible, drop a comment below and I’ll help you figure it out.
